Wednesday, September 18, 2013

Caribbean Nations seek reparations

I recently heard about various Caribbean nations seeking reparations from European nations (see link here) and thought it would be interesting for those in the class to see. This link also discusses how some communities have received reparations for specific events, but never entire nations and not for overall enslavement from Trans-Atlantic Slavery. Various Caribbean nations are seeking reparations (i couldn't find a complete list), but the only nations they are seeking reparations from are the British, the Netherlands, and France. I hope Haiti is among those demanding reparations.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

The Haitian Revolution: Conquerors vs Overcomers

Often times when I think of slave uprisings I usually think of the (supposedly) unsuccessful attempts in the Americas led by slaves whom are often depicted as "vigilantes" such as Prosser, Vesey, and Turner, but from now on I will think of Toussaint L'Overture. From now on I will think of the Haitian revolution. I was of course never taught that there was indeed an unprecedentedly  successful Slave rebellion against European powers and that this unthinkable rebellion led to the founding of an independent nation known as the Republic of Haiti. It is astoundingly  inspiring to know that these men resisted so strongly against the yolk of bondage that they were indeed willing to organize and lay down their lives to disassemble its evils. Such courage confirms that although slavery had wrought unimaginable havoc on their physical bodies it had not been successful in laying a stronghold of its contamination on their minds. These men, though others viewed them as innate slaves, viewed themselves as free men being illegally held against their own will. This idea in and of itself is phenomenal to me, it is the story of the underdog it is the definition of what it means to overcome. For this reason, I see the Haitian Revolution as a story of two actors: the conqueror and the overcomer. A conqueror is one who has the capacity to destroy and lacks the moral restraint not to, one who seiges/forces victory through great brutality. For this reason it is no great feat to conquer. However, an overcomer is one who rightfully obtains victory without regard (or attention paid) to circumstances or rational limitations. An overcomer is the greatest kind of victor because they are one whom has no reason to believe that success is attainable and nevertheless ventures out to do the insane and gain victory. An overcomer is one who succeeds in the name of what is right an in the face of all the odds stacked against them. To me the Haitian Revolution is confirmation that oppression can indeed be torn down and so called conquerors can be defeated. In the story of The Haitian Revolution the French were conquerors but the African men were much more, they were the overcomers. 

The Haitian Revolution: Conquerors vs Overcomers

Often times when I think of slave uprisings I usually think of the (supposedly) unsuccessful attempts in the Americas led by slaves whom are often depicted as "vigilantes" such as Prosser, Vesey, and Turner, but from now on I will think of Toussaint L'Overture. From now on I will think of the Haitian revolution. I was of course never taught that there was indeed an unprecedentedly  successful Slave rebellion against European powers and that this unthinkable rebellion led to the founding of an independent nation known as the Republic of Haiti. It is astoundingly  inspiring to know that these men resisted so strongly against the yolk of bondage that they were indeed willing to organize and lay down their lives to disassemble its evils. Such courage confirms that although slavery had wrought unimaginable havoc on their physical bodies it had not been successful in laying a stronghold of its contamination on their minds. These men, though others viewed them as innate slaves, viewed themselves as free men being illegally held against their own will. This idea in and of itself is phenomenal to me, it is the story of the underdog it is the definition of what it means to overcome. For this reason, I see the Haitian Revolution as a story of two actors: the conqueror and the overcomer. A conqueror is one who has the capacity to destroy and lacks the moral restraint not to, one who seiges/forces victory through great brutality. For this reason it is no great feat to conquer. However, an overcomer is one who rightfully obtains victory without regard (or attention paid) to circumstances or rational limitations. An overcomer is the greatest kind of victor because they are one whom has no reason to believe that success is attainable and nevertheless ventures out to do the insane and gain victory. An overcomer is one who succeeds in the name of what is right an in the face of all the odds stacked against them. To me the Haitian Revolution is confirmation that oppression can indeed be torn down and so called conquerors can be defeated. In the story of The Haitian Revolution the French were conquerors but the African men were much more, they were the overcomers. 

Christophe and his Sans Souci

I decided to write my post on tomorrow's readings in Silencing the Past. As I was reading I became enthralled with Henry I (Christophe) and the significance of Sans Souci. Intended as a symbol of a successful revolution, Sans Souci was more than that. I found it a bit ironic, too. For one, Trouillot comments on how Christophe employed Haitians night and day to build this elaborate palace, some even dying from the intense labor. After such a brutal war, why cause more death at such a trivial expense? Christophe was consumed by wealth and creating visual and concrete structures for the West to interpret as Haiti's progression. He put palaces over people; the very people he was fighting for in the revolution.

Some historians believe Sans Souci is a French term meaning 'no worries.' Others believe Christophe named his palace after a man that he murdered during the revolution, named Sans Souci. This would follow more with his supposed nature. The fact that the most renowned structure in Saint Domingue after the revolution was named after someone Christophe murdered is something else entirely. It puts the revolution in a whole different light, for me. It shows how it was shaded by those, like Christophe, who sought power rather than equality. Power he sought, most of the time, at the expense of other black soldiers like him. Trouillot talks about the 'war within a war,' that pitted native island blacks against congo-born blacks. I didn't know that there was an internal struggle during the Haitian revolution. It reminded me of a quote by Abraham Lincoln: "A house divided against itself cannot stand."
     Tuesday in class we discussed a couple parts of Avengers of the New World that got me thinking, one specifically being the Code Noir. I get that this provided 'a set of rules' and, perhaps, 'structure' to slavery, however, I can't help but wonder, is it just a way of almost 'justifying' an act of inhumanity in the first place? These same so called men that was have already discussed that had the ability to record history in any bias, one sided view would have been of the same political position and social status to write the laws the country would go by. To me, yes, the Code Noir might have provided structure to a chaotic slavery, but I just can't help but wonder if having laws about slavery justified the unjustifiable in the eyes of the slave owners. If they were truly there for structure, they would have been 100% abided by and acts such as burning of slaves legs would not have gone unpunished.
     Today, September 11, when I was in town, I passed white man running and carrying a flag pole with an American Flag on it. About at hour later, in town again, I passed an African American man walking with a bookbag, looking as if he had just left campus and was waking home. He sported a red shirt that read in bold letters across the chest 'Proud to be an American' with an American Flag in the background.
     These two things and our discussion about Haiti and slavery, made me think how similar our country was to this not very long ago and how far we have come. Thanks to some very important people and events in America's past, blacks and whites can both be proud to be American and have the ability to enjoy the same rights as equal citizens.

More problems with history and the Code Noir

Taken together, i think the readings from Tuesday and tomorrow really drive the point home just how shaky a ground the term "history" is founded upon. Truillot's book, Silencing the Past has strongly reiterated the issue as well. 

"Silences are inherent in history because any single event enters history with some of its constituting parts missing. something is always left out while something else is recorded. there is no perfect closure of any event, however one chooses to define the boundaries or that event. thus whatever becomes fact does so with its own inborn absences, specific to its production. in other words, the very mechanisms that make any historical recording possible also ensure that historical facts are not created equal. they reflect differential control of the means of historical production at the very first engraving that transforms an event into a fact." (pg. 49)

Later on in the same chapter, Truillot also discusses the concept of archiving and how that plays into the inherent issues of "history" and recording history as well. He then goes on to mention some of the points he left out in his retelling of the story of Sans Souci and how certain things were necessary and other unnecessary for the reader to get the gist or the story. more so, he also points out how certain points are left out or added depending on the reader - be that, Americans, Haitians, etc. and how the historian or the one re-telling a historical event is generally cognizant of these other facets outside of the story itself. 

one of the earlier posts commented on how certain "good" parts of history should also be told about slavery as well as the bad parts. but i suppose it depends on who is telling the story and who the audience is. from my perspective, the horrific events that happened during slavery aren't told enough. i didn't learn about the commonality of rape (to both Black men and women), of violence against women, of some women inducing their own abortions or killing their own children to keep them out of slavery, of the castration of Black men (and severing of ears, noses, fingers, etc. after or prior to lynching), of the breaking of ankles and the severing of leg tendons (detailed in DuBois' book), the molestation of children, etc. etc. etc. (and that's not even getting into mental/cultural/familial degradations) ...in any of my grade schooling or even college courses. whippings and arduous labor were the worst parts of slavery that i learned in school. And if i were to tell someone else of slavery, i would more and likely leave out the Code Noir due to my feeling of its insignificance. in the larger scheme of things, i don't see it as influential, important, or a testament to the supposed morality of those who put it in place and enforced it (on whatever small scale that may have been). Although, if i was speaking to a crowd who had a more than novice understanding of slavery, and we were specifically on the topic of enslavement in Haiti, it might be mentioned in passing. other than that, it wouldn't be mentioned at all. a Black Code that says 'one can beat their slave...but not too bad' isn't all that revolutionary, from my perspective. 





“By creating a society in which all people, of all color, were granted freedom and citizenship, the Haitian Revolution forever transformed the world” p 7

Growing up, I never really knew much about Haiti. I knew that it was in the Caribbean, it was a third world country, and that an earthquake devastated the island a few years ago. Now, I’ve been exposed to the cultural side of Haiti and the Dominican Republic from friends, but I don’t know anything about the history and it’s relevance to America. My parents never taught be because we have no connection to Haiti. But the more I started reading, the more I realized how closely connected the Haitian Revolution is to American history, especially when dealing with race relations and silencing history.  

              In Silencing the Past, Trouillot states, “ As sources fill the historical landscape with their facts, they reduce the room available for other facts.” The importance of an event or figure doesn’t always receive the amount of attention it deserves when it is written about because others overshadow it. In the Americas and Caribbean, “colonization transformed European ethnocentrism into scientific slavery”, creating a culture that will be based on race and class distinctions to determine citizenship. I thought it was interesting how in American history, slave rebellions are rarely mentioned let alone that they have been successful. Yet, the Haitian Revolution was one of the biggest slave rebellions, acknowledging that Blacks are people. Trouillot says, “ to acknowledge resistance as a mass phenomenon is to acknowledge the possibilities that something is wrong with the system” (p 84). 
            This got me thinking why this history was never discussed in the US. Slave rebellions in the US were often kept a secret or described in a way to make whites the victims. This often cause slave owners to become stricter with their slaves so their slaves won’t partake in the rebellion or believe that rebellion will not accomplish anything.  Rebellions grow because the leaders are able to connect to oppressed people through a mob mentality. Because the Haitian Revolution was a success, if the Americans got wind of this, it might give the slaves hope and motivation that they can overthrow power there. I wonder if slaves in America new about this rebellion, mobilizing and the mindset of slaves would have been different. Would whites view slaves as capable beings that can govern themselves-which a justification for slavery was that Blacks were incapable of being “civilized”? If whites viewed Blacks in a different way would stereotypes and perceptions of Blacks be different? No one knows, but it would be nice to get a history that is relevant to all my identifiers except one, American.