Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Reception

 After I had read The Brief and Wonderous Life of Oscar Wao, I thought it would be interesting to look at the reception that the book had and the criticism that Diaz received from it. The reaction it caused says a great deal about reactions towards Caribbean immigrants literary inputs into the American canon. In 2008, the book won the National Book Circle Award and the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. These are prestigious, competitive and highly valued awards.

From this review in the New York Times,
A. O. Scott stresses the importance of the DR in Diaz's portrait of Dominican-American Oscar. The means by which Oscar is able to bring together his heritage and his present place. This relationship between the two countries within his own identity is a question that plays a role in Oscar's representation of himself, “how to take account of his ancestral homeland — its folklore, its politics, the diaspora that brought so many of its inhabitants to North Jersey and Upper Manhattan.” The way that the DR is presented asks us to view the country as “a breeding ground for outsize destinies and monstrous passions...a small country that suffers from a surfeit of history.” A common theme within books across the course that we have studied - the amount and importance of past within ideas of place, and its position within present consciousness.


The book was criticized by some for this view. Some see Oscar as only satisfied when he manages to have sex, fulfilling an idea of masculinity that Diaz himself criticizes within the novel. Some also argue against the many portrayals of violence as an almost standard, everyday occurrence (mostly against women) – some even branding it a book of horrors. But I disagree; whilst the novel deals with tragedies and violence, it gives them a voice and does not blame victims. Oscar Wao, in my opinion, deserves its high acclaim.

The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao

I just finished the book recently and I LOVED it.  I obviously was a little behind on finishing it but I'm so glad I took time to read the rest over the break.  It was truly a tear-jerker and such an eye opener for me.  We live in such a sheltered world here in the United States, so oblivious to the terrible things going on all around the rest of the world.  I cannot believe that people were treated so terribly (and still probably are today) and there's nothing that anyone could really do about it without having the same exact thing done to them.  From Beli's father to Beli herself to Oscar, the times were so far apart in years, yet nothing really changed over time.  They were each personally attacked by Dominican government officials and brutally beaten almost until death, or actually killed, and nobody even got punished for it!  The Dominican was a place where people had to fear for their lives constantly every single day.  That would be a miserable life to live.  I can't imagine having to watch my every word and movement just to avoid being kidnapped, killed, or imprisoned for the rest of my life.  This book really opened my eyes to the fact that we take our freedom here in the U.S., especially the first amendment, for granted every day.  We can say almost anything we want to and do anything we desire (within the law) and never even think twice about it but these helpless Dominicans, for example the characters in the book, live their lives stepping on egg shells.


I also wanted to say that Beli is in my opinion the strongest woman in the whole book.  She might be portrayed as this terrible mother and like she doesn't love her children, but that just obviously isn't true.  After all that woman went through, it's a wonder she can even still get up in the mornings.  Anyone else who went through something that traumatic and heart-breaking would be just a bitter as she is as well.  I think she is a great mother with her own special way of showing her love.  All she ever did was try to protect her kids and make sure they had what was best for them and earn a living to give them the things they needed.  She worked two jobs, even through a battle with cancer, and still took care of Oscar and his many problems and loved both her children through it all, even if she had a funny way of showing it sometimes.  Tough love is the best kind from time to time.


The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao

This is an interesting read to say the least. 

I honestly dont know where to begin. I cant write about the film "My American Girls" in coversation with this book. The VCR kept messing up the VHS tape. #90sproblems
But the book is a good read, it is about a guy, Oscar, who is pretty much an outcast, for lack of a better word, and has weight problems growing up. While growing up he has issues with his personal life in forms of romance and even tries to commit suicide. 
At the beginning, Diaz, writes about fukú americanus, which is a 
curse of doom on the new world. You can believe that all the bad things that happens in this book are because of this fukú. there is a word to ward off this curse which is "zafa" but it doesnt exactly seem like it helps. 
This brings me to curses in general, sorcery like voodoo, hoodoo, witch craft, indian curses, eypytian curses. Now I do believe in ghosts, dont get me wrong, but it seems like some of these things are a little too out of whack to make any sense, and to have a curse called "Fuku americanus" just seems a little over the top, but thats just my personal opinion. 


                                Caribbean Tainos cultural and religious artifacts called zemis







Just when you think you couldn’t stand Trujillo anymore, Diaz introduces us to Poor Abelard in Five ’44-‘46.  Granted he did come from a privileged background and ran in the unsavory circles of Trujillo and company, though he tried to avoid it. Trujillo’s punishment of him was pretty sad to say the least, I'd never heard of the wet towel around the head & then left him in the sun to fry his brains (sick)! The moral to that story is, don’t wait to see what the Failed Cattle Thief has in store for you when you don’t do as he asks!
The Fuku cycle never seems to end and touches everyone.   I say pobrecita Beli too! Abelard’s third daughter, what a hell of a beginning to lose her father in prison, her mother being ran over, both sisters- one in a pool, and the other by a bullet to the head, not nice.  Beli’s life remains in the toilet, and had it not been for Inca, I wonder if real compassion would have ever found its way to her.
“If you didn't grow up like I did then you don't know, and if you don't know it's probably better you don't judge.”

This quote is applicable any type of judgement, everything from judgment based on race, ethnicity, social class, nationality, clothing, and so much more. What I love about this book ( besides the relaxed language) is the fact that it expresses how judgements are a crucial and acknowledged part of how we construct our identities and our feelings associated with these identities.I know, this might be weird to say this because judgements are so... Judgmental. But to clarify, I mean preconceived notions of people (unfortunately, our society is based on these preconceived notions and is often times socialized into society whether we want to admit it or not). But if you think about, everyone's identity is constructed in reaction to something or someone else, whether it is from rejection or as a reflection of another group. These interactions allow us to notice differences between people and allow one to associate themselves with a group.  Now these identities aren’t always defined by us, rather projected by others who have the power to do so. In Oscar’s case, he was being judged as a man of color by not only mainstream society, but his fellow Dominicans. He lived life in a sort of limbo, not fitting completely into any category. If one is constantly being judge for what they are and what they aren’t, this causes major emotional and psychological problems (attempting suicide twice). As a society, we judge people on their differences, then tell people it's bad to judge and if it happens then ignore it, but then we don’t allow spaces for people to just be themselves, always insinuating that one identity always has to be associated with another.

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Reading Oppurtunities in the Caribbean

In some of the texts we have been looking at, the role of reading and public facilities that facilitate it have affected characters and the ways they see themselves.
In “The Brief and Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao,” Oscar “adored Tolkien” and other authors and was “always hiding at the library.” (p.23) Diaz makes another comparison between life in the DR - where the only book most people have access to and own is the bible - and in America, reading is shown as an opportunity open to everyone, so long as they promise to toe the line and look after the books. All books are available to every immigrant.
In a “Small Place“, the library in Antigua used to be “one of those splendid old buildings of colonial times.”(p.9) But tourists do not rely on library books, they have money to buy their own books and do not have to visit the 1974 earthquake stricken library. All that Antigua’s people have to hold on to is the promise “REPAIRS ARE PENDING” from the original sign in 1974. The differences in facilities of being able to read and learn are unable to be granted to citizens because of the problems left by colonizing governments since independence.
“No Telephone to Heaven” also discusses libraries as a place to learn about the past and education.

From these novels, their novelists are able to discuss the connotations of a life where learning and the joys are reading are not free and accessible to everyone. From the interview, we can see Diaz's enjoyment in discovering that all theses shelves were open to his perusal. Libraries and books offer new and exciting opportunities to the lives of children and adults.