So this week we are reading The Big Truck That Went By by Jonathan Gatz.
As we discussed in class, countries have good intentions to help countries in need, such as Haiti after the eartquake disaster in 2010. But to better tell of the relief efforts made, the author, Jonathan Katz, gives a speech about his book and relief efforts.
http://www.viddler.com/v/faaa1004
http://www.democracynow.org/2013/1/11/three_years_after_the_quake_how
It wont let me insert the videos but go check them out!
Theyre full of information!
Wednesday, November 13, 2013
Presuppositions on Haiti and Fathoming Suffering
The situation detailed in The Big Truck That Went By makes me think about the ways in which I thought about Haiti prior to situations like this (more so, for me personally, it was prior to living in a majority Haitian/Caribbean neighborhood in Brooklyn). prior to those experiences and the people I came to know as friends and close co-workers, was that of all-around devastation; a black hole of suffering. every time Haiti was on the news, it was in reference to some horrible situation and the only time it was spoken of in school was in reference to the Haitian revolution. I didn't even know about the U.S. occupation there until maybe 3 or 4 years ago, reading it in a course here at the university. The more i learned about Haiti, largely through my friends and co-workers, was one of much more....relevance; familiarity. now i could put faces and names onto people and imagine that those i saw on television were my coworkers in their younger years, were their cousins, children, and parents. around the time that i was living there, i also began to learn much more about Haitian Vodun. a Black feminist organization i was a member of had co-founders from Haiti and for one of the events we hosted, it was a Haitian day festival in honor of its independence say (i believe). the spirituality that she invoked and incorporated (visually, verbally, etc.) in my dealings with her really showed me how beautiful and complex of a spirituality it is. all that changes how i viewed Haiti.
i can recall (maybe around this time) hearing someone say that Haiti was the first independent Black nation in the Americas, and that it has been paying for it ever since; meaning that for such a defeat for Black people comes with it unimaginable suffering because of global racism, colonialism, and exploitative business practices. and it certainly seems to be the case. on a spiritual level, i've heard some say that (as Elizabeth mentioned in class) that the improper burials that have been forced to happen (mass graves, no funeral, mutilation and dismemberment of bodies, spiritual ceremonies and rites that don't take place, etc.) due to corruption (large numbers of murders, assassinations, mass shootings) or natural disasters has made Haiti a place that is spiritually unbalanced. i'm learning more, at the present time, about the concept of the Vodun god known as Damballah Hwedo, which is a serpent god that represents ancestors whom are not known by name. it is also symbolic in the US and throughout the diaspora as representation of those lost during the middle passage and the general trauma of enslavement. i think (for Haitians) it's important to look into those types of healing spiritual cosmologies and beliefs to help restore Haiti and Haitians and their well-being - be that spiritual or other. it may even be argued that this concept was elevated to a high level of importance (coming from African traditions) after enslavement and such traumatic experiences.
This is also related to the article: "Suffering and Structural Violence". the article makes me think about the ways in which suffering, for long durations of time (for Haitians, it's scarcely been a calm and stable time since Africans were brought to the island) and how it's difficult to even fathom, really. in this video (around 6:10), J. Lorand Matory, a professor at Duke who studies African diaspora religions/spirituality makes sense of the idea that Haitians are untrustworthy or, by some accounts, even paranoid (in reference to political bodies, the west, governmental structures, and society in general, even their own and in reference to Haitian Vodun). suffering produces emotional scars that are sometimes irreparable. when there's atrocity after atrocity after atrocity, how does one even live? and if someone who lives through such an ordeal, how do they come to terms when their life becomes stable and healthy and more than just survival? it's difficult to even think about.
i can recall (maybe around this time) hearing someone say that Haiti was the first independent Black nation in the Americas, and that it has been paying for it ever since; meaning that for such a defeat for Black people comes with it unimaginable suffering because of global racism, colonialism, and exploitative business practices. and it certainly seems to be the case. on a spiritual level, i've heard some say that (as Elizabeth mentioned in class) that the improper burials that have been forced to happen (mass graves, no funeral, mutilation and dismemberment of bodies, spiritual ceremonies and rites that don't take place, etc.) due to corruption (large numbers of murders, assassinations, mass shootings) or natural disasters has made Haiti a place that is spiritually unbalanced. i'm learning more, at the present time, about the concept of the Vodun god known as Damballah Hwedo, which is a serpent god that represents ancestors whom are not known by name. it is also symbolic in the US and throughout the diaspora as representation of those lost during the middle passage and the general trauma of enslavement. i think (for Haitians) it's important to look into those types of healing spiritual cosmologies and beliefs to help restore Haiti and Haitians and their well-being - be that spiritual or other. it may even be argued that this concept was elevated to a high level of importance (coming from African traditions) after enslavement and such traumatic experiences.
This is also related to the article: "Suffering and Structural Violence". the article makes me think about the ways in which suffering, for long durations of time (for Haitians, it's scarcely been a calm and stable time since Africans were brought to the island) and how it's difficult to even fathom, really. in this video (around 6:10), J. Lorand Matory, a professor at Duke who studies African diaspora religions/spirituality makes sense of the idea that Haitians are untrustworthy or, by some accounts, even paranoid (in reference to political bodies, the west, governmental structures, and society in general, even their own and in reference to Haitian Vodun). suffering produces emotional scars that are sometimes irreparable. when there's atrocity after atrocity after atrocity, how does one even live? and if someone who lives through such an ordeal, how do they come to terms when their life becomes stable and healthy and more than just survival? it's difficult to even think about.
Typhoon Haiyan and Reporting
It
is topical that we consider “Big Truck That Went By” in the wake
of Typhoon Haiyan. There are significant similarities that we can
draw between the Typhoon Haiyan and the Haiti earthquake in terms of
the deliverance of promises of aid, and expectations of what can be
anticipated after disasters. I will look at how the press coverage
has responded to the disaster, and how their coverage explicitly
links to Katz's argument in “Big Truck That Went By.”
After
reading Big Truck, I became aware of some of the fears that come in
the wake of disaster, and how these fears are realized internationally.
In Big Truck, there existed a need within
the aid effort to
“protect women and girls from sexual violence.” (Katz, p.114) The
Press Association wrote that
Ms
Greening, International Development Secretary said “past
emergencies in the Philippines have led to a sharp rise in violence
against girls and women, and in trafficking in particular.”
Violence
against women post disaster is a concern in the Philippines, as it
was in Haiti in 2010.
Another
concern that is reflected in the two disasters is the uncertainty
over the death toll. The Press Association reported that in the
Philippines: “typhoon death toll closer to 2,000 or 2,500, not
10,000, Aquino says.” This was the same precariousness of the
number of dead in Haiti, as Katz explains “Preval told my
colleagues and me that the figure was 170,000. His communications
director corrected him “No, no the official number is 210,000.””
Reporting
the figures of how many have died is difficult to calculate
post-disaster, as the figure continually rises.
The way that Katz argues that much of aid deliveries comes too late, and that preparation for disaster needs to have further organisation in advance is seen in the fact that the Press Association covered that “The UK's first flight delivering urgently needed humanitarian aid to the typhoon-struck Philippines has arrived, the Government has said” today. Even though £13 million was raised in 24 hours, time is of the essence, but so is well-thought out, and considered actions that will not risk lives, or have negative long term consequences. As Katz argues long term projects are required to keep attention and focus kept on disaster stricken areas so that they are not forgotten, and lessons can be learnt from them.
Since
we touched on how children were impacted by the earthquakes devastation, I
posted a few images by children in Haiti.
The
big truck that went by: how the world came to save Haiti and left behind
a disaster, By Jonathan Katz.
What
an emotionally charged subject and area. I like and see the culmination
of everything we’ve been studying in class and how it seems bundled up and
headed towards this work. This works U.S. intention issues relates to what
we’ve been looking at in another class as well, in that there are many scales
that need to be looked at, and equally many policies that have to be addressed
from both sides, not just the ones that are going to benefit the United States
the most. America has to turn on (as the teachers say in elementary school)
our LISTENING EARS! I think that it is ironic that we consider ourselves
the paternalistic one, when many outside our country view us like a spoiled
child. Not that we are not giving,
because we are, and generously. We can
reassess our approach, and ask ourselves are we going to help or hinder? The
question we can ask is, how can we help?
Just a note on misguided intentions,
the women arrested for trying to take Haitian children over the border into the
DR were dealing with and taking legal advise from a man who is “identified as Jorge Torres-Puello, is linked to a network
that trafficked in Haitian and Central American children and is wanted in the
United States, El Salvador and Costa Rica, the National Drug Control Agency
said.” http://www.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/03/19/haiti.baptists.adviser/
Foreign Aid
Its kind of funny we are reading this book now because this is the type of conversation I am learning about in 3 of my other classes. What is foreign aid, what is the purpose, who is it “helping”, and is it effective are just a couple of questions that complicates the simplistic idea of foreign or humanitarian aid and intervention. Madison Bell is no stranger to Haiti. In her book review of The Big Truck Went By , she commends Katz for staying and recording the evidence from an objective standpoint. She praises his devotion to Haiti, even if it means calling out the mistakes and contradictions of not only one of the most powerful country in the world but his home.
However, I found it most interesting the parallels Bell and Katz drew, connecting US occupation during the 1930s to the Duvalier dictatorship and back to foreign aid (mainly US aid). Katz says, “the Americans knew it would be easier to control the country from a single locus of power.” This illusion expresses how detrimental foreign and humanitarian aid is effecting Haiti and other countries alike, even with the best intentions. Similar to how occupations forced Haitians into one central area and how Duvalier tried to centralize the country, foreign aid (water, money, food) was distributed in the cities rather than the rural areas that many people left to after the earthquake. Despite various recommendations to have various supply distribution sites in the rural areas around Port-au-Prince, US aid agencies felt it was more effective to have one major distribution site, in the city. This forced many people to migrate back to their destroyed homes in the cities or if they didn’t live in the city previous to the earthquake, they were forced to find a home among the debris.Like we stated in class as well as in Katz, most aid isn’t direct but rather used to supplement logistics of these aids.
So, after learning and being enlightened about the real issues with foreign and humanitarian aid, what is the most effective way to provide help? What do you all think we think the most practical way to help countries in need? I know I can answer directly, because I’m not an expert, but hopefully we (and I mean us Americans) can find a way to implement balanced foreign aid; providing short-term care but also helping countries accomplish self-sustainability.
Wednesday, November 6, 2013
Aaron Matthews- Director of My American Girls
" Living with the Ortizes — a family I knew long before filming ever began — underscored for me how much you never really know people until you have to walk in their shoes. I've made documentary films before, but never had I followed subjects with the intensity and duration that I did in making My American Girls. You learn so much about people just by sitting around, being patient and waiting for scenes to unfold. And when Aida says "our house is like a hotel for the Dominican Republic," she's not kidding."
This quote was said by Aaron Matthews, director of My American Girls. Even though the video did not work in class I still wanted to do some research into behind the scenes of the movie and the background of the family. Matthews conducted an interview with POV http://www.pbs.org/pov/myamericangirls/interview.php which I encourage everyone to read.
My American Girls: A Dominican Story captures the joys and struggles over a year in the lives of the Ortiz family. They are first generation immigrants from the Dominican Republic, showing how the others from the outside are trying to fit into the American dream.
In class we are always discussing breaking down the barriers of "whiteness" this speaks to both Oscar and the movie. The down played struggles that immigrants must face to fit in, how the crime or action of one person associated with that race can define and catergorize race, class, and gender.
I think to truly accept the hardships that immigrants go through you need to realize where they are coming from. When we think of jobs that Latinos occupy in the US. They are hardworking and do the jobs that us lazy Americans don't want to do. They know how to provide and hustle for their family. Family is very important in the Latin American culture.
I am curious to know if the American-born children of Latino families know and appreciate the strive their ancestors have made or are they unaware of the history before them. I feel as though they themselves are a class of their own.
This quote was said by Aaron Matthews, director of My American Girls. Even though the video did not work in class I still wanted to do some research into behind the scenes of the movie and the background of the family. Matthews conducted an interview with POV http://www.pbs.org/pov/myamericangirls/interview.php which I encourage everyone to read.
My American Girls: A Dominican Story captures the joys and struggles over a year in the lives of the Ortiz family. They are first generation immigrants from the Dominican Republic, showing how the others from the outside are trying to fit into the American dream.
In class we are always discussing breaking down the barriers of "whiteness" this speaks to both Oscar and the movie. The down played struggles that immigrants must face to fit in, how the crime or action of one person associated with that race can define and catergorize race, class, and gender.
I think to truly accept the hardships that immigrants go through you need to realize where they are coming from. When we think of jobs that Latinos occupy in the US. They are hardworking and do the jobs that us lazy Americans don't want to do. They know how to provide and hustle for their family. Family is very important in the Latin American culture.
I am curious to know if the American-born children of Latino families know and appreciate the strive their ancestors have made or are they unaware of the history before them. I feel as though they themselves are a class of their own.
My American Girls and Oscar Wao
I have a noticed a trend of Dominican Immigrants after Reading
Oscar Woa and “My American Girls Documentary” (I remember watching it in WS
470). When Dominican families immigrate to the US, they are search of better
living and to provide a better life for their children as well. Although they
come searching for a better life, they never leave the island mentally. They
always want to keep the DR close to their hearts. Another trend I have noticed
is many Dominican immigrants look forward to going back to the DR to make a
better life there after retirement. A lot of Dominican families struggle
economically and socially after migrating, but that does not stop main purpose
of migration.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


