Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Producing History

The means by which Trouillot first found out about debates on how history is created - by power - was family ideas belonging to his father and uncle, this was thought provoking to me. The closeness they exhibited in talking of historical figures – as if they were people they knew personally through “intimate details”, shows how, as we discussed in class, our recollection of what happened in a memory can be open to different interpretations from others.

If those who we are remembering an event with have diverging ideas as to what actually occurred, different interpretations of major historical events arise. These, in time, have caused shifts and rifts between nations (for example who started …. war?). History making is at its most powerful when such conversations become heated, in the hands of powerful leaders and historians - 'who did what?', and 'how did that affected the other group?' become crucial to the creation of history. When one 'truth' is 'preferred' over another, if a nation is powerful enough, they can have the capacity to try to silence the other from having any claim – and it can be years till this other historicity is heard. Silencing of history, like the Haitian Revolution by Western historians; Alamo, the truth about Columbus' 'discovery', or the Katyn massacre of 1943, only acknowledged by the Russian government in 1991, demonstrate how power changes dynamics in recording history.


Trouillot's family example shows how personal inter/national/family history can become – as if “history sat at the dinner table” with you. And how, for me, this shows how disagreements in family recollections, although not as crucial to the world overall, can be seen as a microcosm of the production and recording of history.
     This past Tuesday, we discussed the difference between history as a fact, something that has actually happened, and historicity, something which is said to have happened. I find this particularly interesting because I have never taken into account the fact that each piece if history is just that, a recorded account of how someone saw something happen or heard something happened. We have, over time, taken that and turned it into our 'history' as a nation and go by it as rock solid evidence that it happened that way when in all reality we weren't there, and, to a certain extinct, do not know whether it is opinionated or bias to a particular view point.
     When asked to remember the story of Christopher Columbus, I wrote down the story as I had recalled it from early childhood and the way I would have retold it. Not only was part of my story inaccurate (the name of the king that sent them), but it also was very 'G' rated. This was how we were told the story as children and how many of us picture the finding of America taking place, when in fact, it was much more gruesome and barbaric than this. 'Avengers of the New World' suggests we interpret many acts of the past such as slavery in a similar fashion, not through the eyes of everyone envolved, but through those writing the story and recording it as our 'history'.
     Often times those recording history, were the educated, upper members of society, not the lower, uneducated members, who were often times the women and slaves. Their stories were mostly told, therefore being lost over time and changed through translations. The title 'Silencing the Past' particularly grabs my attention to this through the word 'silencing'. That is exactly what has happened to unrecorded history and, sometimes, historicity... It becomes 'silenced' and often times forgotten.

The most interesting part of the book so far to me has been the first part of Chapter 2.  This part of the book stuck out to me more than others, partly because I haven't finished reading to Chapter 6 quite yet, but mostly because I've always grown up thinking that slavery, as well as racism, were both really only huge problems in the United States.  Now reading this book plus what we learned in class on Tuesday has really just opened my eyes and helped me to see the topic from a whole different perspective.  Now that I'm aware that slavery actually was a much larger movement in other parts of the world, it's really an eye opener because I grew up thinking that slavery was so bad in America, when in reality, it was very minute compared to other parts of the world.  Also, I have honestly never known that slavery started in other places long before it ever reached America and it was actually introduced to the Native Americans by Columbus on one of his voyages from Europe to Hispanolia around 1501.  Now that I've said all of that, you can obviously tell that I'm not typically a big history person, as far as my knowledge about all of this goes, but I am finding learning all of these new facts very interesting.  Now, speaking of being interesting, what really grabbed my attention in Chapter 2 was when AUTHOR started the chapter with this quote: "I am black.  That is my only fault.  If I could whiten myself you would see, with the will of God, an increase in your wealth."  This quote means so much but is so simple at the same time.  The color of our skin has always been such an important detail in just life in general since probably as far back as history has been documented.  I interpreted this quote as an African American who's fed up with being judged and mistreated by people based on their skin color.  The quote seems to have a patient, yet angry tone at the same time and is trying to get the message across that if people could just be accepting for a second and look past skin color then they would see that this person saying the quote is an amazing person and deserves respect no matter what their skin color might be.  Why has skin color always been such an issue, even back in the 1700's?  Why would someone mistreat a human being the way some of these people were treated based solely on skin color?  I've always felt this way, that everyone should be accepted and treated with respect, no matter if they're black, white, yellow, red, or green.  So, I just thought it was cool that this quote was in our book and it really hit home with me and stuck out in my mind, even if our reading assignment was not really mainly about race. 


If you have never heard this passage before, it is from the book 1984, a satire about government involvement in America’s society and to what extent government power would be over our everyday lives . Essentially, this book is about continuous war, public mind control to keep power within the Inner Party Elites, and. It portrays a society that is controlled by propaganda to keep the citizens uniform in thought, opinion, and generally oppressed. Now, when I first read this book in high school, I thought there was no way America’s society would ever turn an extreme state like this. But the more I started taking classes in college, the more I started to realize that there is so much more to our country’s history that they instill in us from an early age. There are multiple narratives and point of views, but we are only shown through one person’s eyes.
            History and culture are two concepts that are very interconnected. History is important when learning about one’s moral foundation of the country, why certain events happen, and to show the progress of the country into something better. This ties closely to culture because knowing one’s history defines who we are, how we see ourselves, and how we see others.  America is considered to be a “melting pot” – which is a debatable term- because of the variety of races, ethnicities, and cultures. Yet, there is a major disconnect with our education within schools and outside of it. The school system is suppose to complement the learning that isn’t academic, such as cultural capital, how to network, pieces of information like that. But when we are taught in school only one-way perception, it overshadows the external learning because socialization has emphasized academic education as the only way to be successful in our society.

            History isn’t linear; it is way more complex than we think of because of its varying perspectives. By silencing the past, we are in a way living in ignorance because we believe what we taught is the only truth and don’t have the energy or power to find out for ourselves. Even though today’s society isn’t as extreme as the book, it is still very closely related. We are played images through television, the news, and movies “showcasing” different “versions” of American life, oversimplifying and generalizing those who aren’t part of the majority life in America.  Ignorance isn’t strength, freedom isn’t slavery, and war isn’t peace. Limiting people from learning about their personal history and others history hinders us. I believe having a worldview, even if you can’t travel, makes you appreciate your country, your heritage, and your education. It is crucial for feeling like part of a society, which makes you want to make it better.

I especially liked Chapter four in Silencing The Past when Trouillot writes about The World’s Columbian Exposition of Chicago.  Trouillot states, “The Chicago Exposition actually opened in 1893, but by then historical accuracy and even Columbus himself had become quite secondary.” (128)
I was stunned to learn about America’s over the top expense of 5.8 million dollars spent on this exposition during the late 1800’s, and sadden to think how it was not about substance, but that it was all just a money making scheme, and for power and control.  But, then I remembered, oh that was what brought Columbus here in the first place.  I also thought Trouillots line “Some Spanish journalists ridiculed what they saw as a vulgar carnival” (129) they should have popped back around for the advertising extravaganza that was planned a hundred years later “campaigns to make Columbus sell cars and furniture” and what would they have made of that? Those campaigns were dropped.  I think to my self, doesn’t that sound familiar?  Do we ever learn?  I was glad to read some of us eventually do, I like the way Trouillot put it “ In retrospect, the most striking feature of the quincentennial was the loudness of dissenting voices worldwide.  For varying reasons and in various degrees, native and black Americans, Latino-Americans, African, Caribbean, and Asian leaders denounced the celebration of the conquest or tried to redirect the narrative of The Discovery.  For me most poignant of all is at the end of the chapter when Trouillot says Columbus didn’t even have a journal entry in his log for “Friday, October 12, 1492.”(140)

The Past is Key To Moving Forward


I really enjoyed the class discussion this past Tuesday September 4, in regards to the book Michel-Rolph Trouillot’s Silencing the Past. Comparing the narrative Columbus “Discovery of America,” to what we had learned as children vs. what we now know as adults.  

 Trouillot argues that in the writing of history lots of things get lost and whatever is lost impacts our perception of the past. If we are never exposed to certain details we cannot fully develop an understanding of what went on.

Nel and I had discussed that growing up we were both given very peaceful images as to Columbus’s journey to the new world, his search of spices in India and stumbling upon America. We were always told that exchange between the Native Americans and Europeans was quite peaceful and that both parties were eager to learn from each other. Basically all we knew was this….

In fourteen hundred ninety-two
Columbus sailed the ocean blue.
He had three ships and left from Spain;
He sailed through sunshine, wind and rain.
He sailed by night; he sailed by day;
He used the stars to find his way.
October 12 their dream came true,
You never saw a happier crew!
“Indians! Indians!” Columbus cried;
His heart was filled with joyful pride.
The Arakawa natives were very nice;
They gave the sailors food and spice.
Columbus sailed on to find some gold
To bring back home, as he’d been told.
He made the trip again and again,
Trading gold to bring to Spain ( Mama Lisa’s Blog).
I think that at any age it is important to address that he was not the first person to find and explore America. I think that as children get older its important to discuss that Columbus had brought with him the idea of slaves, slavery, diseases, war, violence and trade. On top of that we need to be aware of how the Native Americans felt about explorers being on their land.

Doing this activity brings up and important concept of how from a very young age we are sheltered and limited to just one way of thinking. Never in school did I read anything on the Native American’s aspect of life when the explorers came and took over.


Before I read this book I had no idea about the Haitian Revolution. It was something that wasn’t even talked about in school. Any time we discussed slave revolutions it always had to do with southern plantations pre civil war. The fact that slavery existed in other countries before America still blows my mind.

 I found it interesting the impact The Haitian Revolution had in in the United States. How the people of the south feared that the slave revolution might spread from the island of Hispaniola to the slave plantations of the southern United States. They believed that the Haitian Revolution would inspire slaves to revolt.

My favorite quote of the entire book “But the past does not exist independently from the present. Indeed, the past is only past because there is a present, just as I can point to something over there only because I am here. But nothing is inherently over there or here. In that sense, the past has no content. The past -- or more accurately, pastness -- is a position. Thus, in no way can we identify the past as past." p. 15

The past is only the past because we move on to the present. We have a tendency to overlook the past but the past is key to going forward.