Wednesday, September 25, 2013

The Marine in Saint Domingue

While reading "Taking Haiti" I realized the marine's response to the rebels is significant to the history of Haiti. Landing in Saint Domingue after being pumped with racist and wildy innacurate comics, products, live shows, etc., the marines were probably expecting an island of wild beasts. I wish I could crawl into the mind of Overley and see things as he saw them. I'd like to think he did some serious rethinking of America's occupation there and his personal stake in it. After meditating on "The White Man's Burden," I don't know how I feel about the U.S. in this "big brother" role. I don't know how I feel about referring to other inhabitants of this earth as a burden. It's a fine line that we're constantly straddling. I think the "world police" notion is built on good intentions but I think sometimes we forget that culture is subjective. Pushing your beliefs on others has rarely been successful and is the perfect recipe for resentment and, moreover, the violence and angry action resentment can breed. It seems to me Haiti might as well have been Mars in the eyes of the American marines. Confused and frightened at every sound of the revolutionary conch, I don't think they knew what they had been sent to Saint Domingue to do.

One of the many things that interested me about this book, were the dynamics of the enlisted military men that went into the Marines.  I found it very interesting the various backgrounds, and places of these men being brought together to occupy an island they knew very little about, much less the people who inhabited it. 

These men each one having a different history, and their own formed ideas from their upbringings, as well as all their own personal baggage to drag along, as Renda writes, “In addition to Quakers (Butler was surely not the only “fighting Quaker” in the Marine Corps), other men came to the corps with marked identities:  German, Irish, Slav, Polish, Serbian, Jewish, and others.” (59).  Renda goes on further to say, “For some, including President Theodore Roosevelt, this combination seemed just right. With a war raging in Europe, and U.S. Cities teeming with immigrants-between 1900 and 1915 alone.”(59).  But needless to say, it does not take long for the military to start being selective in their choices, and there is much more interest in recruiting native-born Americans (African Americans not among them) than recruiting some of these particular ethnic groups that they deem to be undesirable to join the Marines.  This is how we begin an occupation, with emphasis on race, class, and bias.

Imperialism and History

When reading Taking Haiti: Military Occupancy and the Culture of US Imperialism by Mary A. Renda, I was interested in the connection between this text and Michel-Rolph Trouillot's Silencing The Past in the production of history and how silences can be created through holes in fact and truth claims. In Renda's text, we use interviews as part of the archive available to us to interpret the events. In 1973 General Noble, Chief of Staff of the brigade said “You can cut that out later. Doesn't sound good anyway” (p.88)When reflecting on impressions he had made of himself when relieving duty from Haiti – this was an American admittance to ignorance of Haitian feeling towards occupation. Ideas of “paternal guidance offered to a child nation in need”(p.42) was supposed to clarify the situation for marines, but it also signaled a further silencing of a truth claim in Haitian history.

This assertion of authority and control (and inherent ideas of superiority) reminded me of examples that Trouillot argued, since “inequalities experienced by actors lead to uneven historical power in the inscription of traces.” (p.48) This raises issues of whether Haitian resistance to domination was recorded in a fair way in historical memory. American marines were not completely prepared to understand the proud “living”(p.45) historical remaining elements of Haitian struggle, symbolised to them in the pumpkins and couch shells.


I also reflected on how important class was, yet again, in instances of conflict with race and gender, but this time within the marines, as on page 56, the racial immigrant status of marines often defined their place in the military hierarchy  and being the “Boy from nowhere, a good for nothing bum”, and so geographical belonging played a role in disgraced.

"The White Man's Burden"- Moving Forward


As we close a chapter in class of the Haitian Revolution and start a new one we are constantly reminded that racism now more than ever is being up rooted, slaves have taken a stance and revolted, which is making the racism line much deeper and defined, in regards to the spectrum of their freedom. Since expressing their voice they have at the same time created a deeper, darker one for the whites.

Looking at “The White Man’s Burden” poem and cartoon I was curious to do more research into the poem and fully understand it, after reading it several times this is what I was able to dissect from it.
Europe is trying to justify coming into Africa and taking over, the white man’s burden has a duty to send “the best of their country to dark, uncivilized places of the earth.”  His view proposes that white people have an obligation to take over, and show Africans the Western ways.
 Through my research I found there is an argument whether “The White Man's burden" can be interpreted as racist, or taken as a metaphor view of non-Western national culture and economic traditions. Giving the Eurocentric   a “meaningful” purpose coming into Africa because they felt an obligation to help them “better” themselves whether they want to or not.  One could argue that they used the Christian missionary movement, which was active at the time in Africa to give a more religious meaning to what they were doing.
 Written in response to Kipling’s poem in April 1899 H.T. Johnson wrote and published “The Black Man’s Burden.”  . A “Black Man’s Burden Association” was even organized with the goal of demonstrating the mistreatment of brown people in the Philippines as an extension of the mistreatment of black Americans at home.
Pile on the Black Man’s Burden.
'Tis nearest at your door;
Why heed long bleeding Cuba,
or dark Hawaii’s shore?
Hail ye your fearless armies,
Which menace feeble folks
Who fight with clubs and arrows
and brook your rifle’s smoke.
Pile on the Black Man’s Burden
His wail with laughter drown
You’ve sealed the Red Man’s problem,
And will take up the Brown,
In vain ye seek to end it,
With bullets, blood or death
Better by far defend it
With honor’s holy breath.
 If not for the Haitian Revolution and the voice of Toussiant Loverture,  I believe that  African slaves and freed ones during this time  would have been too scared to express their voice. Since TS had paved the way   both groups were not afraid to talk back. Whether it was the revolt or the educated African man talking a stand through writing their voice had been heard and was going to continue to be from now until their freedom. 
It’s interesting to see how someone can hate a certain race or ethnicity so much to try and exterminate him or her. Dominican president and dictator, Raphael Trujillo, ordered the Haitian Massacre of 1937 to kill close to 20,000 Haitian immigrants living in the Dominican Republic. At first, it was believed to only kill those not working on the sugar plantations, but then learned to be the death to any Haitians living in the DR. The determinant for life was the pronunciation of the word prejeli, the Spanish word for parsley.  
            Occurring around the same time period, Raphael Trujillo had similar intentions as Hitler did in the Holocaust. The whole purpose was to exterminate a certain race, because people simply did not believe they belonged in society. Still, I found that the most interesting part of this massacre to be the justification many of the Dominican elites used to justify this massacre. They claimed that the Haitian migrant workers were taking poor Dominican jobs and space that should be “theirs” as Dominicans. This massacre was used as a promotion of Dominican national identity.

            I find it astounding that because of the intertwined history of Haiti and the Dominican Republic, the construction of race is completely different. Haitians view Africa as their “homeland” while the DR tries to reject most of their African heritage, choosing to relate to European ideals and characters from “their” ancestors of Spain. As we’ve learned the past few weeks, those whose skin tone held more whiteness were given more opportunities and held more power and prestige because of their class status. Colonization helped create the elite classes after the countries gained independence. But you can’t talk about class without talking about race because the two are closely tied to each other. The internalized racism constructed during colonization has been ingrained in post-colonial culture and continues to be persistent today. This massacre stands out because it is an example of how complicated race relations are and how colonial influence still has legacy in many societies. Its especially interesting in regard to understanding what it means to be African American, not just in the United States, but in Latin America, Central America, and South America.