Thursday, October 10, 2013

Tuesday 10/15

We will be leaving class early on Tuesday to attend this event!  I understand if some of you have class following ours, but those who can attend/stay and write up 1-2 pages, I will offer extra credit toward your blogs.

Wednesday, October 9, 2013

Economic Migrancy

Haiti, in two centuries went from being “the richest colony in the world, ‘The pearl of the Antilles’, to the poorest country in the western hemisphere” (p.26) “Needed but unwanted” shows us the change being part of a context of isolation from other international nations, debts to France post-independence, land reform and the US occupation that we read about in Mary Renda's study “Taking Haiti” and natural disasters. All these factors affected the economic growth of Haiti.
Political and economic causes both play a role in the reasons as to why Haitians decide to migrate out of the country. Uncertainties and lack of security for Haitians act as motivations for leaving. I found the depiction of migration from Jamaica intriguing in “Life and Debt.” As an audience we feel the dichotomy of treatment between holiday makers; .treated in the airports with a sense of luxury and special treatment. Then we compare the experience of real Jamaicans making sojourns abroad, made subject to excessive checks on baggage and passport immigration. Vacationers benefit from the successes of globalisation, their currency gets them a great wad of notes. Whereas actual Jamaicans feel the disadvantages, and this, among other motivations, sparks civil unrest.


 Like Haiti, after independence, Jamaica fell victim to every kind of financial problem. In “Telephone To Heaven,” it is the economic conditions and subsequent migration that Cliff describes in Jamaica. The legacy of colonisation has left economic scars on the future prosperities of post independent countries, and it is this history that create difficult economic conditions.

problematic tourism, free zones, and foreign aid

Life + Debt was very interesting documentary.

I was intrigued by  a number of thing from the documentary. for one, the "free zone" area in Jamaica that is technically not in Jamaica and is pretty much a corporate state of its own in which the corporations that helped build it (along with the IMF) can do whatever they please and not be held responsible by the Jamaican government or its citizens.

second, the issue of tourism has become more and more apparent to me, especially studying within the area of anthropology. the ways in which societies/communities/cultures have to make oversimplified caricatures of themselves to present to the world (generally the western world because the tourists are generally westerners) in order to make a significant profit through tourism is highly problematic. in a number of cases, it adds to the erasure of many societies. it brings to mind a forthcoming book by an American woman who went and stayed with the Maasai of Kenya and claims to be the first female Maasai warrior. being pushed, in a number of ways, to the outskirts of a westernized society (as many traditional societies have been forced to do during and after colonialism), with land and other rights diminishing, communities like the Maasai have turned to tourism to keep their cultures afloat. so now they have tourists coming into their community, trying to make changes, and presenting a novice idea of that society to the west. it's highly problematic, exploitative, and neo-colonial. the same has taken place in Jamaica. Rastafari has come to be a caricature of itself in which smoking pot and wearing red, green and yellow have become a comical image of Jamaica. when in reality, Rastafari is a religion/spirituality that is a complex belief that deserves as much respect as any other belief system. i liked how the director interjected the film with wisdom from Rastas without making them into some comical mockery of what westerners typically think of Rastas. i think documentaries like these should make us more conscious of what types of tourism we partake in and facilitate discussions on the contradictions of helping out nations whose main income is through tourism, while at the same time adding to cultural erasure, simplification, and exploitation in a number of cases.

third, i think the ways in which foreign aid is given to countries by other countries or organizations like the UN, WTO and IMF have to be constructively and actively criticized. we all like to hear that country X has given X amount of money to Haiti or Jamaica or Uganda, but many of us don't know about all the restrictions and limitations accepting that loan or money has on those countries that need it.

Needed But Unwanted

In class we watched a documentary called "Life and Debt" that showed us what Jamaica is like to locals vs tourists. The documentary showed us what Jamaica has become as a country independently. The country does not have enough funds or agriculture to be able to sustain itself as it had planned, leaving itself in debt. This leads me to some of the writing that we have gotten to read.



In the PDF File Needed But Unwanted by Bridget Wooding. It is like many of the texts that we have read in class. It gives us a closer look into the sugar plantations along with Haitian-Dominican relations. This also includes the immigration and migration of workers to the agricultural land. 

While these countries have been around for a while, there is still great obstacles to overcome that locals are facing. In Needed But Unwanted, Wooding writes that, "This said, political reform in the Dominican Republic is an extremely complex and slow process, and there could be setbacks if the Dominican
political and economic crisis of 2003 deepens and endures. Reformers still face a long and difficult battle." (pg 89).

While these countries are still facing change, change is an inevitable thing of the future. 
                                     NO TELEPHONE TO HEAVEN
                                                        Michelle Cliff


No Telephone To Heaven.  No voice to God.  A waste to try. Cut off.  No way of reaching out or up.  Maybe only one way.  No mater if him is Jesus or him is Jah.  Him not gwan like dis one lickle bit. NO TELEPHONE TO HEAVEN.(16)

This paragraph really grabs my attention.  It also reminds me of Trouillot, in Silencing The Past.  The voiceless, and the unheard.   I can’t help but put in this quote from Cliff, “Depression.  Downpression. Oppression.  Recession.  Intercession.  Commission.  Omission. Missionaries.”  Cliff talks more about the no telephone connection line with God, and there is just nothing left for them to feel about the one’s who persecuted them.


The grinding poverty of the dungle, and the stark contrast with the wealthy, Cliff makes very visible in her work.  Like the part where she describes the state of the children in the dungle, and where a beggar lady is in front of the church of the privileged, and there is a sign to help the poor children in Biafra, and the lady just laughs.  Because it is absurd.  Also striking is the mention of the makka-thorned acacia.  The only bush to grow in the dungle. “The bush from which the Ark was carved and the Crown was woven.  And this is only in the beginning of the book.