Wednesday, October 2, 2013

The Farming of Bones

When reading The Farming of Bones and throughout our discussion on Tuesday, I couldn't help but want to look deeper into the symbolism in the novel.

- We discussed the importance of the 'water' in class. Different bodies of water and scenarios involving water were present in the book. This could be representative of the 'cleansing' or 'rebirth' of the characters throughout.

- Another piece of symbolism being Anabelle's dreams and her ability to 'open up' in them. My parents always told me I like to sleep a lot because the dreamer is the real me. Yours dreams are subconscious and uncontrollable, possibly representative of how you wish life was or could be.

- The name The Farming of Bones is symbolic as well. The novel itself is a compilation of different stories from Haitian slaves and workers and the hardships they endured. The 'farming' of 'bones' can be seen as the labor intensive work the plantation, or farm, workers were made to do. 

                                                        PARSLEY

Farming of Bones was an amazing book, one of the best I’ve read in a long time.  It told a story that has been historically ignored or deemed non-worthy of mentioning. The book was so beautifully written, filled with passion. I absolutely loved her descriptions of the physical scars and mutilation on the characters to symbolize the emotional scars on not only the individual, but also all of the persons who were forgotten.
      I found this poem by Rita Dove about the massacre.
           
"Parsley"

1. The Cane Fields

There is a parrot imitating spring
the palace, its feathers parsley green.

Out of the swamp the cane appears
to haunt us, and we cut it down. El General
searches for a word; he is all the world
there is. Like a parrot imitating spring,
we lie down screaming as rain punches through

and we come up green. We cannot speak an R—
out of the swamp, the cane appears
and then the mountain we call in whispers Katalina.
The children gnaw their teeth to arrowheads.
There is a parrot imitating spring.

El General has found his word: perejil.
Who says it, lives. He laughs, teeth shining
out of the swamp. The cane appears
in our dreams, lashed by wind and streaming.

And we lie down. For every drop of blood
there is a parrot imitating spring.
Out of the swamp the cane appears.


2. The Palace
The word the general’s chosen is parsley.
It is fall, when thoughts turn
to love and death; the general thinks
of his mother, how she died in the fall
and he planted her walking cane at the grave
and it flowered, each spring stolidly forming
four-star blossoms. The general
pulls on his boots, he stomps to
her room in the palace, the one without
curtains, the one with a parrot
in a brass ring. As he paces he wonders
Who can I kill today. And for a moment
the little knot of screams
is still. The parrot, who has traveled
all the way from Australia in an ivory
cage, is, coy as a widow, practising
spring. Ever since the morning
his mother collapsed in the kitchen
while baking skull-shaped candies
for the Day of the Dead, the general
has hated sweets. He orders pastries
brought up for the bird; they arrive
dusted with sugar on a bed of lace.

The knot in his throat starts to twitch;
he sees his boots the first day in battle
splashed with mud and urine
as a soldier falls at his feet amazed—
how stupid he looked!— at the sound
of artillery. I never thought it would sing
the soldier said, and died. Now
the general sees the fields of sugar
cane, lashed by rain and streaming.

He sees his mother’s smile, the teeth
gnawed to arrowheads. He hears
the Haitians sing without R’s
as they swing the great machetes:
Katalina, they sing, Katalina,
mi madle, mi amol en muelte. God knows
his mother was no stupid woman; she
could roll an R like a queen. Even
a parrot can roll an R! In the bare room
the bright feathers arch in a parody
of greenery, as the last pale crumbs
disappear under the blackened tongue. Someone
calls out his name in a voice
so like his mother’s, a startled tear
splashes the tip of his right boot.

My mother, my love in death.
The general remembers the tiny green sprigs
men of his village wore in their capes
to honor the birth of a son. He will
order many, this time, to be killed
for a single, beautiful word.

What I liked about this poem is that it humanizes Trujillo. At first, I didn’t understand here point in this poem. I questioned why she would write in his point of view; thinking to myself “ we need more stories about those who have lived through the massacre and those who died”.  But the more I read this, the more I realized her purpose in writing in this point of view. Dove’s is humanizing evil, just like how many of us are fighting to reverse the dehumanizing descriptions forced on certain groups of people.  It shows how Trujillo fought to cover up his sadness and sorrow with getting rid of those who he blamed for his unhappiness.  Now I’m not making excuses for him. He did a horrific thing, and I believe he was completely in the wrong. But we talk about how history has multiple faces and maybe, just maybe, Trujillo has another story, different than the one he was trying to project on others.

Divided Island

Danticat's Farming of Bones made me reflect on how island's are divided and what this can do to the relationships between people over money, poverty, power and hatred. Generalissimo Trujillo decided that the systematic massacre of Haitians in the Dominican Republic was the means by which Dominicans would be able to cleanse their land, economics, nationhood in 1937. From the symbol of the twins at birth, Danticat is able to draw out a narrative of a fight between love and the means to live. 

  The Birthing of Nations – even the birth certificates are noted that it is the “ninety-third year of independence and the Era of the Generalissimo.” Rafi's privileged place in Senor Pico's heart shows how racial pigmentocracy and patriarchal discrimination can even work against ones own daughter. Papi defensively argues that “pure Spanish blood” is of the highest quality in his daughter, Senora, the mother of the twins to Doctor Javier's “impolite assertion” of the twin having “a little charcoal behind the ears.” 

  The divisions between the two nations is something that Amnesty International have investigated in their 2013 report on the Dominican Republic. Haitian people are being intimidated and threatened in their plight of being denied identity documents. The UN have recently protected Haitian immigrants. In 2000 the state was found responsible for the killing of 7 Haitian migrants and mass deportations still continue. 

  With books like Danticat's and the work of organisations like Amnesty International, http://www.amnestyusa.org/research/reports/annual-report-dominican-republic-2013 awareness is being raised to the continuing plight of Haitians in the Dominican Republic and the conditions of cane workers who still see death as “lucky to no longer be part of the cane life, travail te pou zo, the farming of bones.”

Genocide. How do we get here?


There are many interesting dynamics to our latest book, but the most intriguing element to me was the question mentioned in class of how do we get here? How do we get to full on mass murder and genocide? That is a question that has always perplexed me about massacre and even racism in general. What does it take to turn the mind to the point where one human being will depreciate the value of their fellow man’s humanity? It’s a question I still seek the answer, but I have some beliefs about how do we get here, as well as ideas about how do we get FROM here.  The fundamental of racism is an “us” and “them” mentality. It is a psychological fact that whenever human beings are divided into groups they automatically adapt attitudes of group superiority in favor of whom they identify as “our community.” When a person feels a sense of community and begin to see others as “outsiders” or “foreigners” it is obvious to me that whenever any threat to their community arises they will ascribe to nativism theories and develop a disdain for the group they deem as “other.” This otherizing is why you often see spikes of discrimination and genocide arise during times of domestic threats such as economic downturn or wartime. This trend is easily seen in U.S. history with The Naturalization Act, The Chinese Exclusion Act, Japanese Internment camps and recent legislation discriminating against Hispanics and Latinos. The trend isn’t only a western phenomenon; it is also seen in the Holocaust. Hard times, and group rivalry are the perfect storm for xenophobia to turn into paranoia and discrimination to turn into massacre; nevertheless, none of this would be possible without groups. Without “us” and “them” the ethnic cleansings and persecutions seen in the former instances would have no premise, no meaning, and no perceived benefit. This is why I find the federal recognition of the myth that is human race extremely problematic. I find neither legitimate evidence nor any reasonable defense for the use of 17th century mythology in the federal government. There is no case for race in the 21st century. It is not a factor in any genetic code, nor a biological reality or even an adequate determinant of ancestry, geographical orientation, or historical contiguity. Human race is not real, it doesn’t tell you who you’re related to, or necessarily where you come from and it’s not a gene you can pass to your children. Skin color is a human trait that is determined in an identical and equally unphenomenal way as hair color and eye color. It’s a simple human trait like any other and does not account for any feasible genetic difference; but, until that is a publically known and admitted fact I fear that atrocities like the 1937 genocide in the Dominican Republic against Haitians will continue. All in the name of something that is nothing more than sheer illusion. Yet problem with a genocide is that no one ever knows it is one until after it happens because the victims have been “otherized” or defined out of equal humanity. However here are 8 common steps to genocide that we can be on the lookout for to prevent future devastations to humanity. The eight stages of genocide are

1)      Classification: divisions into us and them that may result in social or legal prohibitions of miscegenation.

2)       Symbolization: the use of slurs and derogatory language to describe members of a classified group or the use of physical labels (must wear stars, scarfs etc.)

3)      Dehumanization: depreciating the humanity of another human being. This is shown through social or legal discrimination and exclusion as well as the use of animal names to describe the group

4)       Organization: the forming of groups to carry out the acts of discrimination, exclusion or violence. Doesn’t have to be grand; many genocides were carried out by local officials or groups.

5)      Polarization: the elimination of moderates, caused by situations or happenings (purposeful or not) that force one to “choose a side.” This builds animosity and distance from the other group, which leads to indifference.

6)      Preparation: this includes identification such as listing ones classification (group) on important documents and ID cards. This will make the process of extermination easier and readily transgressed (in Rwanda victims were pulled over and killed routinely in traffic stops)

7)      Extermination: the collective murder of a group (called extermination because the group has been considered vermin, deposable, and expendable), may include mutilation. Victims are often piled into mass graves.

8)       Denial: the mass graves are often hidden, and documents are burned. Admittance of massacre is skillfully avoided with clever terms like “unconfirmed,” “alleged,” and technicalities over the legal definition of genocide are exploited and used as a defense.

 We must also keep in mind that the steps leading up to genocide do not have to be purposeful, or legalized; they sometimes happen as a “snowball” effect over time.
I found what we talked about in class on Tuesday to be very intriguing.  My favorite part of our discussion was learning that the water in "The Farming of Bones" was actually symbolic in the book.  I found this so interesting particularly because I totally missed the symbolism of the water when I was reading the book alone so it was cool to hear that after the fact.  

In class, we discussed how the water symbolized a sense of rebirth, cleansing, escape, and also dreams and emotions to the Haitians.  I thought that was really cool and a clever way of placing underlying messages in the book by Danticat.  When I looked up the symbolism of the water in The Farming of Bones just now, I found that not only did the Massacre River hold symbolism, but also other related bodies of water in the book probably contained symbolism as well.  

The bodies of water in the text related largely to the Haitians and their dreams of freedom because they would go to the stream and wash their bodies off and cleanse themselves before and after working.  They also went to the stream and cleansed themselves with the water the day that they were mourning Kongo's son's death which is why the stream and water seemed to be kind of a freeing act for the Haitians.  Now that I have really thought about it, the Massacre River and other bodies of water in the book truly stand for something bigger.  I believe that the bodies of water symbolize almost a sense of religion and faith that they will one day be able to escape the terrible conditions and trials that they have faced and that one day, through God, they will be free.

url.jpg













Danticat, “Look at you,” he says, taking my face into one of his spacious bowl-hands, where the palms have lost their lifelines to the machetes that cut the cane.  “Yours are glowing like a Christmas lantern, even with this skin that is the color of driftwood ashes in the rain.”(1)
I selected this image as Danticat mentions lanterns many times in her book, and selected this passage because it is about Amabelle and Sebastien.  I like the play on shadow and light, dreams and nightmares, aloneness and security.   There are many moving passages through out this book, and I really enjoyed it in its entirety. 
I was especially drawn to this bold text, where much of it read like poetry and gave one another glimpse into Amabelle, Sebastien, her mother and father.  What was as rewarding was her speaking about her parents in those special moments they shared before she lost them. Danticat, “My father was joyful, contrary to my mother’s quietly unhappy ways,” I admit. “He used to pick me up and try to throw me up in the air, even when I became too heavy to be carried, even when everything he did ceased to seem like a miracle to me.” (33)
Danticat's work so rich that one could smell the lemongrass, the sugarcane, see Man Rapadou’s house, the “red satin ribbon”(67).  The tragedy that unfolded was so moving and sad your heart just aches.  Last line in Danticats poem “Dawn” Dawn has not yet come, We want to stop crying, The funeral masses have been sung, We can not longer weep, Come on family, Let us mourn.

Fanals, which are miniature, lantern-like homes that are part of Haiti's Christmas tradition. A candle placed inside illuminates the fragile craft and creates a stained-glass effect. The size of either a shoe box or as small as a camera, fanals are often placed in windows to light the way.