The film Life and Debt provides insight into the contrast between the Jamaica we as tourists "know" and the real Jamaica suffering under crippling debt and poverty. The movie chronicles Jamaica's independence in 1962 to now and asks the question "are we worse off now?" I personally have been to Jamaica on a cruise line and the movie shocked me how accurate Jamaica is portrayed to tourists like myself. Even in the news today we don't hear about Jamaica's struggles.
While watching the film in class on Tuesday I was constantly reminded of the "big brother" role the U.S. has taken upon itself. The relationship between Jamaica and America is a perfect example how this interaction can leave a country at a standstill. What stuck out to me is how Jamaican farmers are unable to sell in their own market. One of the farmers said something that I found so profoundly stirring: "We're fattening a few people at the expense of a culture." Right on. That is exactly what this big brother role has created: a stifling of culture. As if Jamaican farmers could even begin to compete with the market monopoly of America. To suggest they could even have an equal competition is insulting and unrealistic.
I always thought the independence of a country would lead the way to better things. I just think that culture and social norms are relative and cannot be applied universally. And I would go so far as to make the claim that debt is also a relative concept. How could Jamaica meet the demands of the bank without a functioning and profitable economy?
Wednesday, October 9, 2013
The Identity Crisis
I can really like No
Telephone to Heaven. Mostly because I can relate to Clare’s perceived identity
crisis. The confusion of her “mixed” identity is amplified in her constant
inability to fit in no matter what place or space she places herself in. I think
one’s racial (thus social) identity crisis is not caused by not knowing who you
are in the context of yourself but in the context of a world interrupted by
colonialism that insists on living with a pre-colonial mindset. A post-colonial
world using pre-colonial standards of identification will leave anyone who
thinks long enough confused. It is not that you are lost but that the world has
not updated its understanding of you to a 21st century globalized context
which leaves you frustrated. It’s not that you don’t know who you are; it’s
that you can’t be who they expect you to be. It’s not black and white for you.
The illogical logic of race has no application to a 21st century
body. Think of the way we label people “African American”, or the way people say
I’m French or I’m Jamaican because their grandparents were from there, or those
who would claim “I’m half-Italian.” I mean how can you be half a nationality? How
can a Jamaican be born in America, or an African be born in Alabama? This is
impossible in reality, but apparently not in racial theory. It is these inconsistencies
that leave one without identity in a world with such outdated categories. My
parents have been here longer than most Europeans so how am I still fall under
the hyphenated category of African but whites are just American? And how could I
be African and American? I was either born in one place or the other. So I was
born in America yet oftentimes I find myself feeling like a foreigner here. It
cannot be because my forefathers were immigrants because the founding fathers
were immigrants. It feels like I am an outcast in my own home. Does
African-American simply mean that I am and my children will always be refugees
in their own homeland? That we will never be welcome, that we will never be
able to fly the American flag in our yards here in Smalltown, AL without
feeling mixed feelings and a conflict of identity? Will the second-border of
whiteness as American always be so tightly patrolled to disbar people of color from
the American identity? Being American seems to have a silent (white) in front
of it. It appears that all others are not truly included within the definition
of American if they do not first fit into the structure of whiteness. We are constantly
disenfranchised from partaking in the social atmosphere of our peers because to
them we are African. We are “different.” Because of my their (American)
whiteness and my blackness, many see themselves more related to people across
the world than to the people they grew up in the same city with. Whiteness
means that you are the same as an Englishman and I am the same as an African.
But I have nothing in common with a continent on which I have never lived. We don’t
eat the same foods, or speak the same languages, yet we are supposed to be
culturally identical, more so than my English speaking hamburger eating peers.
Yes, somehow I am grouped in the geographically proximity with people millions
of miles away and not with the person across the table from me. In some insane
way I am considered historically contiguous with millions of people in numerous
countries and numerous continents that me nor my ancestors ever stepped foot
on, but not with the country we grew up in. This is the logic of race theory.
It can leave people of color like me and Clare frustrated with the confusion of
the world’s delusional duality expressed in the term African-American, or with
the word “Creole” and leave people not of color oblivious to their own
identities as a citizen of the world and nothing more, as my kinsmen and nothing
less. It is the aforementioned logic that is confused, not our identities. It
is the system that is lost, not I. I am American. That sentence doesn’t confused
me one bit, but it will confuse the ones around me who want to label me by an
outdated, disproven system of human race that is perplexed that I have not need
to fit into it.
“No Statue of Liberty for them – oh, no—their emblem of welcome,
going almost unnoticed until Kitty commented on it, was a small sign obscured
by the cracked and boarded-up glass of an abandoned NAACP office they passed on
their way out of Miami. A MAN WAS LYNCHED YESTERDAY, it said. “Hello, America,
“ Kitty muttered to herself, after repeating the worlds on the sign for her
family.”
-No
Telephone to Heaven p 54
The passage was so deep to me. We are taught in school that
all Americans are created equal; deserving of equal rights to education,
protection, health care, and equality in every sphere of the opportunity
structure. Even though these values have become ideological norms enforced by
various forms of social institutions, minorities, especially those that
identify or are identified as blacks that have been historically and presently
oppressed learn other methods to negotiate the feelings of otherness. However,
this is not the perception the United States wants to give the world. We are
seen and act like the “super power” of the world, influencing various countries
in their economies, politics, and even culture. However this “unified front” is
false because of the racial power structure prevalent in today from the
colonial periods.
Its
interesting to talk to people who aren’t from the US or when we travel outside
the US talk about America. How people want to come to live the “American
Dream”, to be in the land of opportunities. Yet, if one doesn’t fit into
certain categories, they must learn how to adapt to societies subtle norms of
inequalities: sexism, racism, and classism. This quote just expresses how romanticized
America and its equal opportunity structure is really just an abstract reality.
It's More to Jamaica then Coconut and Rum
The film Life and
Dept talks about the ugly part of Jamaica that tourists do not see. The ugly
part of Jamaica that tourists fail to see. Media only portrays the pretty
beaches,mountains, songs, dancehall, and great food. The media fail to portray
Jamaica as poverty, corrupt, and basically as modern day slavery. Jamaica may
have their independence but they are not free. Globalization is the central
control over Jamaica. Jamaica is still passively controlled by outside
countries although they do not have a government. It is funny to think that
tourists do not get a chance to see harm they are causing to the country, then
they decide to vacation in Jamaica. Coconuts and Rum are the only worries of
Tourists.
No Telephone to Heaven describes Jamaica at its purists
form. Jamaica is viewed as a helpless overlooked island. The title of this book
implies Jamaica is in so much bad shape that God even fails to help them.
Jamaica can’t even get any love from God and he doesn’t hear their prayers although
they are constantly praying.
Jamaica is described as dangerous and corrupt. Human bodies
are unimportant to the people in Jamaica. No one is protected by the
government. There is a lot of interracial prejudice on the island. Spirituality
is very important to the island, although the first half of the book and the
title hints that God overlooks the island just like everyone else. The island
is portrayed as helpless.
No Telephone To Heaven
It's very interesting to me how the book is titled No Telephone to Heaven. There seem to be underlying messages throughout the book which involve the title of the book. The first metaphor that I noticed first that seemed to have a relationship to the title of the book was in Chapter 2 when it is clear that Christianity is a central component of the people in Jamaica. I also noticed that it seems that the Jamaican people almost feel betrayed and forgotten by God because of their low positions in society and dreadful way of living. When the book mentions that "No telephone to Heaven" is painted on the sides of the truck in which all the light and dark skinned people are riding in, I couldn't help but see a connection there. These people feel helpless and forgotten by God. They feel that there is no point in "talking" to God because he can't or won't do anything to fix their situations and I believe that this very reason is why the previous owners of the land had this phrase "no telephone to Heaven" painted on the sides of their trucks.
Another instance that I noticed the title No Telephone to Heaven having a metaphoric relationship with the text in the book was when the author finally informed us in the dialogue that Christopher killed Paul and his family during Christmas time. This specific incident has a connection to the title because Christopher seems to be taking revenge on Charles and his whole family for the fact that his grandmother died and he is all alone and that God has not been there to help him when he needed help the most so now he has to live a life of suffering. The book says that the family is in a deep sleep which is described as "the sleep of the righteous" which is also strange because maybe this also has a connection to the title and how they are sleeping so peacefully but Christopher never gets to experience "the sleep of the righteous" and so he also takes revenge on the family because of that reason too.
Needed but unwanted
I liked how the book bridged
the past to the present. I think about how two words come to mind for me, and
those are intractable conflict, and that being with many Dominicans prejudice,
ignorant, and racist views towards Haitians.
Regarding the human rights and the crisis of
1991, I am struck by the naiveté
(although I shouldn’t be) by the United States allowing the Dominican
Republic to convince us that they would try to “improve conditions for cane
cutters and to halt some of the most blatant abuses.”(74) Those abuses that had
and have been going on for quite some time.
Who did we think was going to oversee this? If it had not been for other voices and some
of those voices coming from the Dominicans own church, speaking out for the
migrant sugar cane cutters, we might never have gotten the full picture of what
was still happening with the continued abuses. At the same time the Dominican
Republic was still denying that abuses were going on. The Dominican Republic went a step further and
expelled an estimated 35,000 Haitians, not counting people who left on their
own accord. This explosion was
indiscriminate, it mattered little whether Haitians were born there or
not. It never ceases to amaze me how
little we have moved forward with the treatment of our fellow human beings. How
long will The Dominican Republic be operating in this antiquated system?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
