Wednesday, October 23, 2013


Puerto Rican Day Parade!


As we close our unit of the Caribbean, crossing into the 20th century we are looking at the culture and place of Latin identity through the lens of immigration.  Watching this movie I saw the impact that the Latin American community had on the United States. By 1920 there were over 100,000 Latinos settled in the US, they had taken over Brooklyn and the Upper Eat Side of Manhattan.

            Like with most immigrants the Latinos were terrorized and were surrounded by racism, however they were in a class of their own. People had no idea what to categorize them as, they weren’t white but they weren’t black either.  However they became an important part of American culture and are one of the reasons we prospered so well as a country.

            Being from New York I had always seen the Puerto Rican Day Parade in passing. I saw the colorful floats, the street dancers and the overall excitement of the energetic Latino people proud of their history and culture shouting in the streets.

            The National Puerto Rican Day Parade takes place annually along Fifth Avenue in Manhattan, on the second Sunday in June. It is to honor the nearly 4 million inhabitants of Puerto Rico, but also the 4 million people of Puerto Rican birth or heritage in the United States.
  The first parade was held on Sunday, April 13, 1958, in Spanish Harlem “El Barrio. “ However it has since moved to Fifth Avenue in New York City.  I find this ironic because we as the US once again are trying to take over something and make it our own by striping the true meaning of the parade to make it commercial by putting it on 5th avenue.

In 2007, the parade celebrated its 50th Anniversary with more than 100,000 marching participants and nearly three million spectators along the parade route.


Puerto-Rican-Day-Parade_V1.jpg 

Friday, October 18, 2013

on my disassociation with "tourist" label

I wanted to clarify my stance of identifying with the "native" as opposed to the "tourist" in reference to the excerpt we spoke of in class from A Small Place.

I would agree with Kenya in questioning the position of those who genuinely go to places to learn. however, i think there is a strong distinction between those that go to certain places to learn, and those that go simply for vacation as tourists. Tourists are (and i think Kincaid would agree with this) are people that go to a place outside their country, who mindlessly and obliviously consume and partake in things, for the sole purpose of having fun and getting away from their boring and mundane lives. the people participating in drinking contests, sitting on the beach all day, who get their hair braided and only stay at hotels with a beach-front view...are tourists. They don't think about the people serving them, playing music for them, they don't have much interest in learning about the local experience outside that of molded and entertaining stereotypes, they eat American/European foods while on these vacations, who want to take pictures of everything (and everyone) and do so without feeling any responsibility or questioning of the larger schemes and hierarchies of power. race, capitalism, imperialism, etc. in those interactions and relationships. I've spoken with people who talk about touring a remote area or a rural village, and when asked about what tourism has done or is doing or can do for this community or nation, the response is along the lines of "tourism helps this nation. these women making _______ and these men doing ______ for tourists is a main source of income for a lot of them. they wouldn't have jobs if it weren't for us [tourists]". but when asked WHY it is that these nations and communities have had to resort to dancing/making baskets, jewelry, masks/performing/hosting/entertaining/etc. in order to make a living, they draw a blank. digging deeper into histories concerning colonialism, imperialism, exploitative importing and exporting practices, embargoes, and the like are altogether ignored and/or prioritized somewhere below their need to get away and have fun.
In contrast, someone who goes to a place to genuinely learn is not going to be going to those touristy spots. if one goes to New York city to learn about the experience, the cultures and communities that live there, etcetera etcetera...they don't need to go to the statue of liberty or the brooklyn bridge or whatever. they need to go to Flatbush and Crown Heights and Washington Heights, and corner store bodegas and take the subway or dollar cab (as opposed to a yellow cab). and i'm sure the same is for anywhere in the Caribbean. If i go to Jamaica, i'm not going to get my hair braided, drink for 3 hours straight, sit on the beach for 5 hours, and then retreat to the party hosted my my hotel (which has nothing but other people from my country in it). this is in stark contrast to someone who goes to learn. yes, there are some touristy things one can do, even if they are going to learn and i'm not saying there is a concrete line between tourist and a "learner" (it's more of a spectrum, i would say), but there are some things that are done mindlessly and there are some things done with genuine interest for knowledge, and more often than not, they don't overlap.

maybe this has to do with me being in the area of anthropology, and the subject/object; emic/etic positions are constantly being discussed that i'm maybe hyper aware of them. and given the highly problematic history of anthropology, i think most present-day anthropologists are more aware of the average traveller on these issues. but i most definitely identify with the native and that position as opposed to the tourist because i'm constantly critical of it - as someone who is (subjectively) "American", and as an (amateur) anthropologist.

additionally, i also identified with the native in that i think Kincaid is largely talking about the white tourist (in the excerpt, it was something along the lines of "You don't look like us"). and in general, i identify with the Native, the person of color, the "Black Jamaicans" who are working as custodians and cooks and entertainers in these restaurants, because that is what i have done and have felt sometimes (although not in the same context). For example, i remember maybe seeing a documentary in the works about gentrification in Harlem, and a young woman spoke about how Harlem, her home, has been turned into a tourist destination. she mentioned bus-loads of white people driving by on the street she and her mother walked to church on sunday mornings (the tours are on Sundays, specifically, and have to do with....the Harlem Renaissance, i suppose, and showing people the "Black Church" experience - Harlem style). she said that sometimes they would stop and would take pictures of her. when her mother asked them to stop or turned down their requests for photos, she would see them behind mushed and cars still taking her photo. it just shows how not so far removed from the past of colonialism in which we [Black people/Africans/indigenous peoples/non-Europeans] were seen as spectacles. and of course, there are Black Americans who go to the Caribbean with these same mindless mentalities, but i think the overwhelming majority are white people, and if we are understanding this from a historical perspective - with colonialism, human zoos, human exhibitions of "natives" - the "tourist" would simply be a euphemism for "white people". even when Black people are the travellers, we're still not in the category of "tourist". i recall my best friend telling me of when she took her ex-boyfriend to Mexico (she's Mexican, he's African-American with locs). she told me that people were trying to get photos with him, touching his hair, asking her questions about him like she was his trainer or something and generally treating him like a spectacle (he's tall and has shoulder-length locs, regular clothes, sight-seeing like everyone else). James Baldwin also wrote about his travels to Sweden (and other European countries) in which he also mentioned being looked out as if he was from Mars. my point is that i identify with the native because i associate the native with the Black person, regardless of class, gender, or geographic homleand or place of origin.

Discussion with Sweatshop Workers

In reference to the discussion on Tuesday with the two women from the Alta Gracia in the Dominican Republic, I was underwhelmed.
For one, going off of the little bit that I do know about sweatshops and the type of exploitation that goes on in them, i didn't learn much from this discussion with these women, partly due to the set-up by the students and partly due to the lack of context that was given from the women. This may or may not be, in part, due to a language barrier, and the types of hierarchies that gives especially people of color in the Unites States context, but i certainly believe it played a factor.

I would like to have gotten more context from what exactly is happening in Alta Gracia as well as the whole of the Dominican Republic. The way the discussion was framed, with interjections and tangents on what has happened in sweatshops in China and Vietnam veered off course of the topic. I think it also homogenized the sweatshop experience as if all those who work in sweatshops have the same experiences. Oh course, they're almost all, across the board, exploited, disrespected on multiple levels, and dehumanized. But i don't think the shift in geography, national histories, and cultures are to be unacknowledged when discussing these situations. For example, from the film that we watched in class - Life + Debt - it showed the "Free Zone" in Jamaica and how that operates outside Jamaican jurisdiction and legal codes. It is a sweatshop, and the women working in them also share the process of being exploited, but it is somewhat different from other areas in which these sweatshops are "legal" in contrast to this "free zone" operating on its own, corporate legal domain.

The history of how sweatshops came to be (which is information we got from Life + Debt, that helped me to better understand the "free zones" in Jamaica) would have been helpful. Not to mention, a larger framework and discussion concerning race, gender, class, and how all those intersect and impact this situation in sweatshops would also have been helpful. Overall, i think if the department of Gender and Race studies had hosted this "event", it would have gone much more smoother, and there would have been much more to learn than simply about a good situation happening in Alta Gracia. it's great that Alta Gracia has that situation, but i think most people still need to be educated on the sweatshop situations outside Alta Gracia.

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Why visit and live in place populated by people you can't stand



According to Jamaica Kincaid, "A tourist is an ugly human being." That is a quote I pondered on throughout the book. I honestly do not understand the meaning of her saying this. Well, I understand what Jamaica Kincaid is saying about tourist and I understand why Antiguans are frustrated by tourist. However, I oppose, a little, to the statement. I am little biased towards it. Antigua is a beautiful country with a rich history. What is wrong with a person wanting to experience the country?
Jamaica Kincaid said the Antiguans cannot stand tourist. I understand that a lot of tourist come into the country, naïve and ignorant of the history, and take advantage of the country’s good. But in “tourists” defense, tourist is such a broad term. Not all “tourists” are ignorant to their history. Some tourists really want to learn about the country. I don’t understand categorizing all tourists as stupid, empty, and ugly. In No Telephone to Heaven Jamaicans express their dislike towards tourists. On some level, I understand their anger. But once again “tourists” is a much generalized term.
I love how Jamaica Kincaid talks about people (Europeans, Americans, East Indians) living in Antigua who dislike Antiguans. Who do not like to communicate or associate with them, although they decided to move to a heavily black populated area. That is just plain stupid and that is something that no one will understand.

When reading No Telephone to Heaven, and through the struggling of identity Clare goes through, I couldn't help but think about our discussion last week we had when I asked the class in general if African Americans were discriminated against within their own community. I was shocked and intrigued at the responses given, not only were the answers across the board yes, but I was also shocked to understand the referencing to being 'a white girl' with given circumstances. I was completely ignorant to that concept prior to that particular discussion, but definitely intrigued.  Clare goes through a certain similar identity struggle as far as her nationality, race, culture, and social standing goes throughout the novel.