Toni Morrison on White Supremacy
Thursday, October 3, 2013
Wednesday, October 2, 2013
Nationlism
I am still quite enamored with The Farming of Bones and this whole history that was unknown to me less than a month ago.
Another point that I have gone back to thinking about is the issue of nationalism and the molding it does with ethnicity, racial identity, community, and family. When the nation-state is formed, in order to unify the people (and in making it easier to get them to fight for, die for, pay taxes, or work themselves to death for), every nation, it seems, has had to formulate some image of what they want their nation to be and then molded the people within that, killed or severely oppressed the ones that didn't fit with it, and created campaigns to get certain members to feel that this country was for them. The idea of patriotism is quite interesting as well. Just in the U.S. context, how easily one can be swayed or how being "unpatriotic" is seen as such a bad thing in this country just shows how this idea takes root without people properly questioning it. I felt like it was such a great critique Muhammad Ali put out when he was drafted for the Vietnam war when he said he had no issue with the Vietnamese. He related the issues of Black people in America still being treated as second-class citizens, and the hatred Black soldiers who returned from WWI received to how absurd it was that they expected him to have some false sense of patriotism. And even at that time, with few civil rights, Black people still felt that this was their nation; we were "Americans". This forcible consciousness of Americanism and patriotism takes root even when one is blatantly and overtly dehumanized and legally discriminated against. I think it just shows how strong and imperceptible these ideas are and how difficult it is for us to break away from. They are intertwined with our own personal and collective identities.
Which brings me to my point about nationalism in reference to the Dominican Republic and other Latin-American nations. How does one separate themselves from the nationalism of their/a nation while maintaining an identity that is acknowledged comes from that specific area? I think it's even more problematic when we talk about islands that are complete (or nearly complete, in the case of Hispanola have two nations on it) nations. This is the case for the Dominican Republic, Puerto-Rico, Cuba, Grenada, etc. How can someone from Cuba step outside the nation-state of "Cuba" and claim their own ethnic, social, cultural identity? Is it possible to embrace the social and cultural changes and situations that have come into being from that island, colonial, cultural-mixing atmosphere without equally embracing that nation? Because many Cubans, I've heard, might say "I'm not Black [white, Latino, etc.], I'm Cuban." Understandably, their identity is their own and it is whatever they say it is, but given the problematic nature of these nations, how does one separate themselves from it?
For example, i personally have issues with identifying with the United States or as an American. It relates to issues of oppression relating to people of color, sexism, classism and a slew of political issues that I cannot respect in this nation, but also because of circumstances and activities the U.S. has carried out overseas and in other nations. Identifying with this nation, even though it is my birthplace, is problematic. Yet, how does an African-American identify get formed and outside of that? Indeed, it is formed by those issues of oppression and second-class citizenship.
Overall, I think the issues surrounding nationalism have to be addressed properly and in-depth if we are to truly unpack why atrocities such as the Parsley Massacre happened and yet there are Dominicans who still proudly proclaim that they are Dominican. How is the pull of nationalism and patriotism so strong that it will allow people to kill or turn a blind eye to killings done in the name of their country (because while some Dominicans helped Haitians, there still was no mass uprising against Trujillo or the government in general, and Dominicans are still celebrating their independence from Haiti, still using Haitians for back-breaking labor while paying them pennies, and still denying their Blackness).
Another point that I have gone back to thinking about is the issue of nationalism and the molding it does with ethnicity, racial identity, community, and family. When the nation-state is formed, in order to unify the people (and in making it easier to get them to fight for, die for, pay taxes, or work themselves to death for), every nation, it seems, has had to formulate some image of what they want their nation to be and then molded the people within that, killed or severely oppressed the ones that didn't fit with it, and created campaigns to get certain members to feel that this country was for them. The idea of patriotism is quite interesting as well. Just in the U.S. context, how easily one can be swayed or how being "unpatriotic" is seen as such a bad thing in this country just shows how this idea takes root without people properly questioning it. I felt like it was such a great critique Muhammad Ali put out when he was drafted for the Vietnam war when he said he had no issue with the Vietnamese. He related the issues of Black people in America still being treated as second-class citizens, and the hatred Black soldiers who returned from WWI received to how absurd it was that they expected him to have some false sense of patriotism. And even at that time, with few civil rights, Black people still felt that this was their nation; we were "Americans". This forcible consciousness of Americanism and patriotism takes root even when one is blatantly and overtly dehumanized and legally discriminated against. I think it just shows how strong and imperceptible these ideas are and how difficult it is for us to break away from. They are intertwined with our own personal and collective identities.
Which brings me to my point about nationalism in reference to the Dominican Republic and other Latin-American nations. How does one separate themselves from the nationalism of their/a nation while maintaining an identity that is acknowledged comes from that specific area? I think it's even more problematic when we talk about islands that are complete (or nearly complete, in the case of Hispanola have two nations on it) nations. This is the case for the Dominican Republic, Puerto-Rico, Cuba, Grenada, etc. How can someone from Cuba step outside the nation-state of "Cuba" and claim their own ethnic, social, cultural identity? Is it possible to embrace the social and cultural changes and situations that have come into being from that island, colonial, cultural-mixing atmosphere without equally embracing that nation? Because many Cubans, I've heard, might say "I'm not Black [white, Latino, etc.], I'm Cuban." Understandably, their identity is their own and it is whatever they say it is, but given the problematic nature of these nations, how does one separate themselves from it?
For example, i personally have issues with identifying with the United States or as an American. It relates to issues of oppression relating to people of color, sexism, classism and a slew of political issues that I cannot respect in this nation, but also because of circumstances and activities the U.S. has carried out overseas and in other nations. Identifying with this nation, even though it is my birthplace, is problematic. Yet, how does an African-American identify get formed and outside of that? Indeed, it is formed by those issues of oppression and second-class citizenship.
Overall, I think the issues surrounding nationalism have to be addressed properly and in-depth if we are to truly unpack why atrocities such as the Parsley Massacre happened and yet there are Dominicans who still proudly proclaim that they are Dominican. How is the pull of nationalism and patriotism so strong that it will allow people to kill or turn a blind eye to killings done in the name of their country (because while some Dominicans helped Haitians, there still was no mass uprising against Trujillo or the government in general, and Dominicans are still celebrating their independence from Haiti, still using Haitians for back-breaking labor while paying them pennies, and still denying their Blackness).
Deeper Meanings
After finishing the novel, I came to realize deeper meanings
and points Edwidge Danticat was trying to express to her readers. Throughout
the novel, Amabelle was searching for answers. Amabelle was trying to piece
together the reasons for everything that has happened to her. It seems as if
she always lose the people who are closets to her. She was looking for answers
to why she lost them. In my opinion, I think that’s why Danticat had many
scenes of Amabelle replaying the moments of her parent’s death. Even at the end
of the book, Amabelle was still searching and looking for answers for Sebastien’s
disappearance.
As I revisit the novel, I think about the first and last
lines of the book and what they are symbolizing. “His name is Sebastien Onius.”
Why does Danticat start off with this sentence? In my opinion it shows how
significant this character is and who he really represents. Danitcat also
starts off with Amabelle remembering her parent’s death at the beginning of the
book as well. This also makes me believe that although her parents weren’t
significant characters in the novel, they are extremely important to the deeper
meaning. The book ends with “He, like me, was looking for the dawn.” I think
Amabelle was searching for answers about the massacre.
Amabelle described that she wanted to be “carried into the
river, into Sebastien’s cave, my father’s laughter, my mother’s eternity”.
Sebastien and her parents represent Haiti!!
Farming of Bones Wrap-Up
The
Farming of Bones was a beautiful book that I truly loved having the chance to
talk about and discuss in class. Breaking up into groups and covering the
chapters was helpful in pulling apart each idea and character. The overall
context was clearer because of our discussions.
I wanted to address some of the symbols in the book that
I found and were opened up to in our class discussions. The ending scene of Annabelle descending into
the water shows that water is symbolic of life and death, but in this case
readers are expected to come to their own conclusions regarding the river. Water can be a symbol of baptism, starting a new
with cleansing or it can mean drowning /suffocation, which is what Annabelle’s
parents went through.
The birth of the
twins represents the neighboring nations of Haiti and The Dominican Republic.
The Dominican Republic was represented by the stronger, lighter skinned, male
baby, and the weak, dark skinned, female child portrayed Haiti. It was interesting when I got to the scene where
the lighter baby had died. Senora had underestimated her daughter because she
had darker skin and painted the picture that the lighter twin would be
stronger. When, much to our surprise, the male child is the one that dies it
symbolizes the underestimated strength of Haiti, and the uncertainly of the
future ahead.
Lastly there is Sebastian he represents Haitian people. He is a character who shows us the context of
what the Haitian people were dealing with. The scars he bears his lost hope and
voice gives the reader insight and a human connection to the people.
“His name is Sebastien Onius. Sometimes this is
all I know. My back aches now in all those places that he claimed for himself,
arches of bare skin that belonged to him, pockets where the flesh remains
fragile, seared like unhealed burns where each fallen scab uncovers a deeper
wound."
The Farming of Bones
The Farming of Bones is by far the best piece of writing that we have read this semester.
While I was unable to attend class tuesday, I have done my readings and find what everyone has said in relation to the book and what was discussed in class as very informative.
This book has made me think a little more into the different aspects of race more than the other books we have read this year. Also the symbolism used in this book are interesting. Such as when it comes to Parsley. This is a major piece of the book and helps shows the way the world was in the Dominican Republic.
And the fact that this is read as a novel allows you to connect better with the characters and allows readers to be more enticed with the story.
The Farming of Bones
When reading The Farming of Bones and throughout our discussion on Tuesday, I couldn't help but want to look deeper into the symbolism in the novel.
- We discussed the importance of the 'water' in class. Different bodies of water and scenarios involving water were present in the book. This could be representative of the 'cleansing' or 'rebirth' of the characters throughout.
- Another piece of symbolism being Anabelle's dreams and her ability to 'open up' in them. My parents always told me I like to sleep a lot because the dreamer is the real me. Yours dreams are subconscious and uncontrollable, possibly representative of how you wish life was or could be.
- The name The Farming of Bones is symbolic as well. The novel itself is a compilation of different stories from Haitian slaves and workers and the hardships they endured. The 'farming' of 'bones' can be seen as the labor intensive work the plantation, or farm, workers were made to do.
- We discussed the importance of the 'water' in class. Different bodies of water and scenarios involving water were present in the book. This could be representative of the 'cleansing' or 'rebirth' of the characters throughout.
- Another piece of symbolism being Anabelle's dreams and her ability to 'open up' in them. My parents always told me I like to sleep a lot because the dreamer is the real me. Yours dreams are subconscious and uncontrollable, possibly representative of how you wish life was or could be.
- The name The Farming of Bones is symbolic as well. The novel itself is a compilation of different stories from Haitian slaves and workers and the hardships they endured. The 'farming' of 'bones' can be seen as the labor intensive work the plantation, or farm, workers were made to do.
PARSLEY
Farming
of Bones was an amazing book, one of the best I’ve read in a long
time. It told a story that has been historically
ignored or deemed non-worthy of mentioning. The book was so beautifully
written, filled with passion. I absolutely loved her descriptions of the
physical scars and mutilation on the characters to symbolize the emotional
scars on not only the individual, but also all of the persons who were
forgotten.
I
found this poem by Rita Dove about the massacre.
"Parsley"
1. The Cane Fields
There is a parrot imitating spring
the palace, its feathers parsley green.
Out of the swamp the cane appears
to haunt us, and we cut it down. El General
searches for a word; he is all the world
there is. Like a parrot imitating spring,
we lie down screaming as rain punches through
and we come up green. We cannot speak an R—
out of the swamp, the cane appears
and then the mountain we call in whispers Katalina.
The children gnaw their teeth to arrowheads.
There is a parrot imitating spring.
El General has found his word: perejil.
Who says it, lives. He laughs, teeth shining
out of the swamp. The cane appears
in our dreams, lashed by wind and streaming.
And we lie down. For every drop of blood
there is a parrot imitating spring.
Out of the swamp the cane appears.
2. The Palace
The word the general’s chosen is parsley.
It is fall, when thoughts turn
to love and death; the general thinks
of his mother, how she died in the fall
and he planted her walking cane at the grave
and it flowered, each spring stolidly forming
four-star blossoms. The general
pulls on his boots, he stomps to
her room in the palace, the one without
curtains, the one with a parrot
in a brass ring. As he paces he wonders
Who can I kill today. And for a moment
the little knot of screams
is still. The parrot, who has traveled
all the way from Australia in an ivory
cage, is, coy as a widow, practising
spring. Ever since the morning
his mother collapsed in the kitchen
while baking skull-shaped candies
for the Day of the Dead, the general
has hated sweets. He orders pastries
brought up for the bird; they arrive
dusted with sugar on a bed of lace.
The knot in his throat starts to twitch;
he sees his boots the first day in battle
splashed with mud and urine
as a soldier falls at his feet amazed—
how stupid he looked!— at the sound
of artillery. I never thought it would sing
the soldier said, and died. Now
the general sees the fields of sugar
cane, lashed by rain and streaming.
He sees his mother’s smile, the teeth
gnawed to arrowheads. He hears
the Haitians sing without R’s
as they swing the great machetes:
Katalina, they sing, Katalina,
mi madle, mi amol en muelte. God knows
his mother was no stupid woman; she
could roll an R like a queen. Even
a parrot can roll an R! In the bare room
the bright feathers arch in a parody
of greenery, as the last pale crumbs
disappear under the blackened tongue. Someone
calls out his name in a voice
so like his mother’s, a startled tear
splashes the tip of his right boot.
My mother, my love in death.
The general remembers the tiny green sprigs
men of his village wore in their capes
to honor the birth of a son. He will
order many, this time, to be killed
for a single, beautiful word.
What I liked about this poem is that
it humanizes Trujillo. At first, I didn’t understand here point in this poem. I
questioned why she would write in his point of view; thinking to myself “ we
need more stories about those who have lived through the massacre and those who
died”. But the more I read this, the
more I realized her purpose in writing in this point of view. Dove’s is
humanizing evil, just like how many of us are fighting to reverse the
dehumanizing descriptions forced on certain groups of people. It shows how Trujillo fought to cover up his
sadness and sorrow with getting rid of those who he blamed for his unhappiness.
Now I’m not making excuses for him. He
did a horrific thing, and I believe he was completely in the wrong. But we talk
about how history has multiple faces and maybe, just maybe, Trujillo has
another story, different than the one he was trying to project on others.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

